Sam Smiths new music video has sparked outrage

Sam Smith’s new music video has sparked outrage

“Pornography extreme”, “vulgar”, “Hypersexualized” is the kind of reaction to Sam Smith’s new music video. Still, the video isn’t much different from what popular artists have released in recent years. Rather, Smith’s gender identity and appearance are disruptive here, many netizens respond.

Sam Smith has released the music video for his single “I’m Not Here to Make Friends” to coincide with the release of his new album “Gloria”. The clip features Smith in extravagant outfits, including a matching nipple-drop corset, as well as numerous dancers and extras, including French drag queen La Big Bertha in a luxurious castle.

It’s not the first time we’ve seen dancers in leather pants or champagne bottles splashing in their faces in a music video. However, I’m Not Here to Make Friends reacted strongly to some media and English-speaking netizens.

“It is neither good nor healthy for our society”

Good Morning Britain guest journalist Alex Phillips said the music video was reminiscent of “extreme pornography” with its references to BDSM culture.

According to the former Brexit Party MEP, the video normalizes pornography, which would lead to “a rise in sexual assault and the breakdown of relationships”. She says: “It’s not good or healthy for our society and it is [le vidéoclip] a symptom.

• Also read: Queer people tell us why they don’t want to be in the office

Alex Philips worries that this type of content is accessible to young people online: “It’s nice to block kids from seeing it, but they’ve got tablets and phones, they’ll see.”

She’s not the only one calling for the clip to be blocked on YouTube for users under the age of 18. Oli London, a British web personality who became known for his numerous cosmetic surgeries to mimic the face of one of the members of the K-pop group BTS, also said on Twitter: “Kids as young as 5 can search and watch [la vidéo] without restriction ! […] It’s tremendous!”

Other netizens have compared the British artist to the controversial Andrew Tate, who faces human trafficking charges in Romania. “Andrew Tate is in jail for free and this man isn’t? Disgusting,” one tweeted.

“Sam Smith is the perfect example of what degenerate Hollywood culture is doing to people,” tweeted Dominique Samuels, a conservative political commentator. “It makes celebrities vulgar, hypersexualized and obsessed with their sexuality, which they wear like a costume […]»

homophobia and grossophobia

However, according to several commentators and netizens, what sets Sam Smith’s clip apart from other well-known artists isn’t its content, but rather its gender identity and appearance. Smith, who uses the pronoun iel, came out as a non-binary person in 2019.

• Also read: When inclusivity is just a marketing argument

With transgender rights contested in both the UK and US, and queer people regularly accused of perverting youth in right-wing media, it’s no wonder someone was suggestively staged in a shocking clip, says journalist Daisy Jones in a column for British Vogue.

Smith’s performance was also cited to explain the outrage. The alluring staging would not have elicited a response “if Smith had been thin and cisgender,” argues a culture commentator in The Independent.

Several netizens also raised the issue in order to defend the British artist against criticism that came not only from conservative commentators. “If Harry Styles wore the same thing on a magazine cover you would have screamed ‘YAS QUEEN’,” one user tweeted, explaining the double standard we use to judge queer and fat people.

See also: