Directed by Kenyan Wanuri Kahiu, “What Would It Be If…?” unfolds in an insightful and innovative way, examining the life of Natalie, an aspiring illustrator played by Lili Reinhart with a balance of tenderness and determination. The film is notable for its approach to parallel realities, a narrative technique that challenges conventional linearity and takes the viewer on a “what if” journey, exploring the different facets of the protagonist’s life.
In this cinematic work, Kahiu demonstrates a remarkable ability to weave stories intertwined with human complexities. April Prosser’s script, enriched with subtle nuances, offers an indepth examination of Natalie’s decisions, their consequences and the alternative paths her life could take. Starting from a pivotal moment a graduation ceremony where Natalie is torn between two life options the film unfolds in two parallel narratives.
In one reality, Natalie chooses single motherhood and faces challenges in a repressive family environment, marked by compelling performances from Luke Wilson and Andrea Savage as her parents. On the other hand, she travels to Los Angeles, where she faces new challenges in the competitive world of entertainment. This duality of experience is captured with cinematography that oscillates between the warmth of family life and the impersonal glitz of Hollywood.
The film does not limit itself to a mere character study; He deals with social criticism and the portrayal of the workplace in Hollywood. The character of Nia Long, a once idolized film director and now a tyrannical boss, illustrates the adversities Natalie faces in her professional journey. This aspect of the film reflects the reality of many aspiring artists, depicting both the dreams and disappointments of the industry.
“What If…?” ends with a connection between the two narrative strands, consolidating Natalie’s experiences into a single reality in which she achieves professional and personal success. Kahiu’s decision to merge the two stories into a happy ending can be seen as an expression of the fact that, regardless of the decisions made, there is always a path to fulfillment and love. This outcome may seem a bit simplistic for such a complex plot, but it provides an optimistic and satisfying conclusion to Natalie’s journey.
The film also pays homage to cultural icons like Hayao Miyazaki’s acclaimed “Spirited Away,” enriching the narrative with references that resonate with audiences. Not only is this shot a nod to the influence of anime and animation on pop culture, but it also serves as a parallel to Natalie’s journeys of selfdiscovery and transformation.
“What if…?” is a captivating cinematic reflection on the decisions and paths that shape our existence. Kahiu and Prosser create a narrative that is at once an exploration of the individual and a commentary on broader social issues. This film is a testament to cinema’s ability to make us think about the “what ifs” of life while entertaining us with a welltold story and unforgettable performances.
Movie: What if…?
Direction: Wanuri Kahiu
Year: 2022
Genres: Comedy/Drama/Romance
note: 9/10