The passage of a mysterious bolide through our solar system in 2017 had stunned astrophysicists, one of whom went so far as to see it as alien technology. A study published Wednesday offers a “non-alien” explanation for the exotic visit.
• Also read: The risk of a collision with an asteroid in 2046 is decreasing
“Oumuamua” — which means “scout” in Hawaiian — was spotted by a telescope in Hawaii and was moving at such fast speeds it could only have come from another star system, and this was a first.
The discovery has upset the astronomical community, which has long been searching for comet-like objects entering our solar system from the far reaches of space.
Except that Oumuamua didn’t look like the usual comets: it didn’t have that characteristic hairiness formed by its immense halo of gas and dust as it approached the Sun.
The approximately 100 meter wide interstellar visitor was also distinguished by its brilliance and a large variation in brightness, which gave the impression of a metallic object rotating on its own.
But even stranger, after orbiting the sun, ‘Oumuamua accelerated and went off course, propelled by a mysterious force that ejected it from the solar system.
The scientists were stunned, and ended up with four months of incomplete and seemingly conflicting data they were trying to figure out. A whole series of theories arose from this.
Some “were beyond imagination,” Jennifer Bergner, an astrochemist at the University of California, Berkeley, who co-authored the study published in Nature, told AFP.
• Also read: The James Webb telescope discovers an asteroid the size of the Roman Colosseum
Trapped Hydrogen
According to his explanation, regardless of its origin, Oumuamua is a water-rich, comet-like object. During its journey through interstellar space, it was exposed to cosmic rays that bombarded the water and released hydrogen, which became trapped in the object’s body.
As the bolide approached the sun, the heat in turn released the trapped hydrogen and acted as an “engine” that sent it on an unexpected course.
“Trapped hydrogen is simply the most general explanation,” says Darryl Seligman of Cornell University and co-author of the study in a press release.
• Also read: Four asteroids flew past Earth in early March
This work “provides without a doubt the first simple and realistic explanation of the peculiarities of this object,” commented Marco Micheli, astronomer at the European Space Agency (ESA).
But not everyone agrees with these conclusions. Starting with Avi Loeb, former director of Harvard University’s astronomy department: the eminent scientist had argued that the most believable scenario is that ‘Oumuamua is an extraterrestrial ship.
A controversial thesis he defended in 2021 in a book entitled The First Sign of Extraterrestrial Intelligent Life.
Asked by AFP about studying nature, the astrophysicist confirms that saying a comet has no tail “is like saying an elephant is a zebra with no stripes”. He recalls that Comet 2I/Borisov, the second visitor from outside the solar system discovered in 2019, had a long dusty hair.
Jennifer Bergner’s answer: If Oumuamua is tailless, it’s probably because it’s much smaller than any comet observed so far – including 2I/Borisov.
The situation could change soon. Observations from the Vera C. Rubin Telescope in Chile, scheduled to begin in 2025, are expected to discover many new comets both inside and outside the solar system. If the smaller signs show them releasing trapped hydrogen and lacking a tail, like Oumuamua, that would confirm the theory, the astrochemist added.
As for the possibility of extraterrestrial intelligent life, “it all depends on the level of evidence required,” comments the scientist.
“We’ll never know exactly what Oumuamua was – we missed our chance. But for now, I think we have a compelling non-alien explanation,” she concludes.